An independent secular reference about argumentation and logical tricks. It is not the website of a religious community, sells nothing and is not connected with the former site on this domain.

an honest argument: a secular reference on argumentation

An honest argument: telling a strong point from a clever trick

We argue every day: about where to go in summer, how much salt to put in the soup, who should clean the stairwell and whether children need a school uniform. Almost any argument can be conducted so that both sides come out of it wiser, or so that they part offended and none the wiser. The difference rarely depends on the topic. More often it depends on how the arguments are built and whether someone is replacing honest reasoning with a move that merely imitates victory. This reference explains what an argument consists of, how to recognise common tricks and how to check your own reasoning before the other person does.

A good argument is like working together: two people are looking for an answer that will stand up to scrutiny, not for a way to make the other one fall silent. A victory won by a trick proves nothing and usually costs trust.

— Editors' thought

Where to start

Thesis and argument

What exactly is being claimed, what supports it and how the conclusion follows from the premises. A short glossary of the concepts you need to take any argument apart.

Tricks in an argument

Attacking the person, the false dilemma, changing the subject, the straw man and other moves: what they look like in everyday examples and how to respond to them.

How to argue without falling out

Three everyday arguments taken apart: what went wrong, at what point the conversation turned into a quarrel and how it could have gone differently.

Check your own arguments

Questions worth asking yourself before a conversation starts: what your opinion rests on and what could change it.

Reference sections

  • History

    How people learned to argue: ancient conversations, the sophists, the school tradition of logic and modern argumentation theory.

  • Ideas

    Thesis, argument, premise, conclusion, sophism, burden of proof and other concepts in plain words.

  • Figures

    Socrates, Plato, Aristotle and the roles people play in an argument: arguer, opponent, moderator, listener, judge.

  • Sources

    How to read an ancient dialogue in summary, a table of tricks and the steps for taking apart someone else's argument.

  • Analysis

    Everyday arguments taken apart: a holiday, parking in the courtyard, school uniforms. Plus the catalogue of articles.

  • Timeline

    Key points in the history of argument: from the conversations of Socrates and Aristotle's treatise to the present day.

  • FAQ

    Short answers about this reference, about logical tricks and about how to argue without falling out.

How to take apart someone else's argument in five steps

  1. What exactly is being claimed

    Put the other person's idea into a single sentence in your own words and ask whether you have understood them correctly. Half of all arguments end at this step: it turns out the two sides were talking about different things.

  2. What it rests on

    Find the grounds: the facts, observations and general rules the conclusion relies on. Ask yourself whether both of you know these grounds, or whether the other person finds them obvious and you do not.

  3. Has the subject been changed

    Check whether the claim you started with is being proved, or quietly a different, more convenient one. For example, you were arguing about whether a recipe is good, and what is being proved is that the cook tried hard.

  4. Is it a personal attack or a false choice

    If instead of an argument you hear a judgement of the person, or you are offered only two options where there are more, that is a signal to stop. A trick does not refute an idea; it only leads the conversation astray.

  5. What would change your mind

    Answer honestly what information would make you agree. If no such information could exist in principle, you are no longer arguing but defending yourself, and it is useful to notice that in time.

About this reference in brief

Is this the website of a religious community or a temple?

No. This is an independent secular reference on how to argue honestly. It does not represent any community, temple or religious organisation and does not deal with questions of religion.

Do you teach how to win any argument?

No, we teach how to argue honestly. The aim of this reference is not to outtalk the other person but to reach, together with them, an answer that stands up to scrutiny. Sometimes that means admitting the other person is right.

Can this be used in political arguments?

This reference does not deal with politics, and we take our examples only from everyday life. The ways of taking an argument apart are universal and described in general terms; where you apply them is up to you.

Where does the information come from?

From textbooks of logic and argumentation theory, and from summaries of ancient texts, above all Aristotle's treatise on tricks and Plato's dialogues. We do not quote; we put the ideas in our own words.

About the project

This is an independent secular reference. It is run by a small editorial team interested in how people reason, why conversations so often end in a quarrel and what helps people argue to the point. We are not connected with any organisations, do not run classes and sell nothing.

This reference has no connection with earlier websites on this domain and does not reproduce their content.

We write calmly and use everyday examples: an argument about a holiday route, a pie recipe, the rules of a school meeting. Such examples are clear to everyone and make it possible to see how an argument is built without being distracted by the passions that loud topics stir up.

  • Ideas

    Thesis, argument, premise, conclusion, sophism, burden of proof and other concepts in plain words.

  • Sources

    How to read an ancient dialogue in summary, a table of tricks and the steps for taking apart someone else's argument.

  • Analysis

    Everyday arguments taken apart: a holiday, parking in the courtyard, school uniforms. Plus the catalogue of articles.

  • FAQ

    Short answers about this reference, about logical tricks and about how to argue without falling out.

Sources

  • Textbooks of logic and argumentation theory
  • Aristotle, "On Sophistical Refutations" (summary)
  • Editorial materials of this reference

Names and dates in this reference have been checked against logic textbooks and summaries of ancient texts. Everything else is set out in general terms and with everyday examples, without judging particular people or events.