FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Here are the questions readers ask most often: about the reference itself, about how arguments are built and about how to apply all this in everyday life. The answers are short; you will find details in the sections we link to.
An honest argument begins not with the ability to object but with the willingness to listen. Someone who hears the other person argues more briefly and more precisely, because they object to exactly what was said.
How the material was selected: a question makes the list if it can be answered briefly and to the point, based on logic textbooks and the sections of this reference, without judging particular people.
About this reference
What is this website?
An independent secular reference about argumentation and logical tricks. We explain what an argument consists of, how to recognise dishonest moves and how to argue so that the conversation benefits both sides.
Do you run classes or prepare people for debating competitions?
No. We are not a school or a club, we do not run classes and we sell nothing. This reference simply gathers and explains information found in logic textbooks.
Why are the examples so everyday?
Because the structure of an argument is easiest to see in simple examples. When a topic stirs strong feelings, it is hard to notice a trick, but in an argument about a pie recipe it is obvious at once.
Can summaries of ancient texts be trusted?
A summary always simplifies. We try to convey the general idea, relying on textbooks, and we do not attribute to ancient authors words they did not say. For a deeper acquaintance it is better to read the texts themselves in a good translation.
About arguments and tricks
How does an error differ from a trick?
An error is made by accident; a trick is used on purpose. Outwardly they can look the same, so it is sensible to assume an error first and check what the other person meant.
If I have spotted a trick, does that mean the other person is wrong?
Not necessarily. A trick shows that this particular argument proves nothing, but the thesis may turn out to be true for other reasons. Looking for tricks in someone else's speech is not a way to win but a reason to ask for a real argument.
Is it possible to do without tricks altogether?
Completely, probably not: we all reason carelessly at times. But you can learn to notice tricks in yourself, apologise for them and return to the point. That is far more useful than catching others out.
How to argue and check yourself
How do I know it is time to stop an argument?
If both sides have repeated the same arguments several times, if the conversation has turned to judging each other, or if it has become clear that you differ in values rather than facts, it is better to pause and agree to come back to the topic later.
How can I check my own arguments before a conversation?
State your thesis in one sentence, write down what it rests on and ask yourself what could change your mind. If there is no answer, it is worth asking whether you are defending a habit rather than an idea.
What should I do if the other person starts attacking me personally?
Do not respond in kind. Calmly say that you are ready to discuss the question, not each other, and repeat the question itself. Most of the time that is enough to bring the conversation back to the point.
How can I admit I was wrong without losing face?
Say plainly which argument convinced you. This shows that you are changing your mind not out of weakness but because you heard a strong argument. In an honest argument such an admission earns respect, not mockery.
See also
- Ideas
Thesis, argument, premise, conclusion, sophism, burden of proof and other concepts in plain words.
- Sources
How to read an ancient dialogue in summary, a table of tricks and the steps for taking apart someone else's argument.
- Analysis
Everyday arguments taken apart: a holiday, parking in the courtyard, school uniforms. Plus the catalogue of articles.
- History
How people learned to argue: ancient conversations, the sophists, the school tradition of logic and modern argumentation theory.
Sources
- Textbooks of logic and argumentation theory
- Editorial materials of this reference
Names and dates in this reference have been checked against logic textbooks and summaries of ancient texts. Everything else is set out in general terms and with everyday examples, without judging particular people or events.