An independent secular reference about argumentation and logical tricks. It is not the website of a religious community, sells nothing and is not connected with the former site on this domain.

History

Historical context

People have always argued, but at some point they began to think about arguing itself: why some arguments persuade while others only irritate, and how a real refutation differs from a clever conjuring trick. Logic and argumentation theory grew out of these reflections. Below we briefly describe how this happened, relying on the few reliable dates and setting out the rest in general terms.

The history of argument shows that tricks are as old as conversation itself. Only one thing is new in each era: the wish to call a move by its name so that it stops working unnoticed.

— Editors' thought

How the material was selected: we identified several large stages and attached to each only what is confirmed by logic textbooks and generally accepted summaries of ancient texts. Details that sources disagree about are left out.

Stages

Four steps through which the idea of what an honest argument is, and how to recognise a dishonest one, took shape.

Arguments in the ancient world

In ancient cities the ability to speak in public was highly valued: it decided whether you would persuade your neighbours, an assembly or judges. Along with this skill came a question that still concerns us: is what is persuasive the same as what is true? The answer turned out early on to be no, and that was the start of a conversation about the rules of argument.

Figures

The sophists and their tricks

The sophists were teachers of eloquence who undertook to teach people to win arguments. Over time the word took on a note of reproach: it came to describe people who skilfully create the appearance of being right. Aristotle, who lived from 384 to 322 BC, devoted the treatise "On Sophistical Refutations" to such moves and examined exactly how they work.

Sources

The school tradition of logic

Aristotle's logical works were later collected together and called the "Organon". For many centuries logic was studied as a compulsory part of education: students memorised the forms of correct reasoning and the names of typical errors. Many of these names have reached modern textbooks almost unchanged.

Ideas

Modern argumentation theory

Later, researchers noticed that a real argument cannot be reduced to strict formulas. People reason in ordinary language, rely on the plausible rather than the proven, and argue not only about facts but about values. Argumentation theory studies exactly these conversations and offers ways to assess arguments in a real exchange.

Analysis

What links these stages

At every stage people were solving the same problem: how to tell an argument that really proves something from a move that merely makes an impression. Only the tools changed. The ancient conversationalist relied on a sequence of questions, the school logician on memorised rules and the modern researcher on careful analysis of live speech.

Two simple conclusions follow for the reader. First, if you feel you have been caught out but cannot explain where the catch is, that catch has most likely long been described and has a name. Second, knowing the names does not by itself make an argument honest: it only helps you stop in time and ask what the conversation is really about.

  • Figures

    Socrates, Plato, Aristotle and the roles people play in an argument: arguer, opponent, moderator, listener, judge.

  • Sources

    How to read an ancient dialogue in summary, a table of tricks and the steps for taking apart someone else's argument.

  • Timeline

    Key points in the history of argument: from the conversations of Socrates and Aristotle's treatise to the present day.

  • Ideas

    Thesis, argument, premise, conclusion, sophism, burden of proof and other concepts in plain words.

Sources

  • Aristotle, "On Sophistical Refutations" (summary)
  • Plato's dialogues (summary, in general terms)
  • Textbooks of logic and argumentation theory

Names and dates in this reference have been checked against logic textbooks and summaries of ancient texts. Everything else is set out in general terms and with everyday examples, without judging particular people or events.