An independent secular reference about argumentation and logical tricks. It is not the website of a religious community, sells nothing and is not connected with the former site on this domain.

Sources

Texts and sources

Ideas about honest argument have reached us through texts: ancient dialogues, treatises, later textbooks. In this section we show how to read an ancient dialogue in summary, gather the most common tricks into a table with everyday examples and suggest a sequence of steps for taking apart any argument.

A trick that has a name loses half its power. Calmly naming the move is often enough to bring the conversation back to the point and make the other person think about what actually supports their idea.

— Editors' thought

How the material was selected: the table includes the tricks most often described in logic textbooks and easy to spot in everyday conversation. All examples are everyday and invented; any resemblance to real people is coincidental.

How to read an ancient dialogue in summary

Plato's dialogues are the main source of what we know about how Socrates conducted a conversation. The conversation usually goes like this: someone confidently states an opinion, and Socrates asks them a series of simple questions. Having answered them, the speaker discovers that their opinion contradicts other things they agree with.

When reading such a dialogue in summary, follow not who is right but how the path is built. Which claim is being tested? What consequences are drawn from it? At what point does the contradiction appear? This line of thought is useful today too: asking the other person a clarifying question is often more honest and more effective than objecting straight away.

Remember too that a dialogue is a literary work. The characters say what the author needs to develop the idea, and not every line should be taken as a record of a real conversation.

Table of tricks

TrickWhat it looks likeEveryday exampleHow to respond
Attacking the personInstead of an argument, a judgement of the person: their age, experience, character"What do you know about pies? You've never baked one"Agree that your experience is limited and return to the question: so is there too much sugar in the recipe or not?
False dilemmaOnly two options are offered, although there are more"Either we go to the seaside or we sit at home all summer"Name a third and a fourth option and suggest comparing them all
Changing the subjectSomeone starts proving not what was being argued about but something close and more convenientThe question was whether the new uniform is comfortable, and what is being proved is that it looks niceRecall the original question and ask for an answer to exactly that
Straw manThe other person's position is retold in a distorted, absurd form, and that version is refuted"So you want cars never to come into the courtyard at all?" in reply to a request not to park by the entranceCalmly repeat what you actually suggested
After this, therefore because of thisIf one thing happened after another, it is declared the cause"I changed the flour and the dough didn't rise, so the flour is to blame"Ask what else changed and suggest trying again
Generalising from one caseA conclusion about everything is drawn from a single example"We went to the mountains once and it rained, so the mountains always mean rain"Acknowledge the bad experience and ask how representative it is
Appeal to the majorityA thesis is treated as proven because many people think so"All our friends go south, so that must be the best holiday"Reply that popularity is a reason to take a closer look, but not an argument
Circular reasoningThe conclusion is hidden in the premises from the start"This recipe is the best because it is better than all the others"Ask for an argument that does not just repeat the thesis in other words

Steps for taking apart an argument

  1. Find the thesis

    Write down in one sentence what exactly the other person is claiming. If you cannot put it into words, ask them to clarify before you argue.

  2. List the premises

    Note which facts and general rules they rely on. Often one of the premises is not said out loud, and that is the one you actually disagree with.

  3. Check the link

    Does the conclusion follow from the premises? If the premises are true, must the conclusion be true as well, or is a link missing between them?

  4. Look for tricks

    Check against the table above: is there a personal attack in the reasoning, a false choice, a change of subject or an appeal to the opinion of the majority?

  5. Separate facts from values

    Work out what the argument is about: how things are, or what matters more. The first needs checking, the second needs agreement.

  6. Phrase your reply charitably

    Set out the strong version of the other person's idea, and only then explain exactly what you disagree with and why.

  • Ideas

    Thesis, argument, premise, conclusion, sophism, burden of proof and other concepts in plain words.

  • Analysis

    Everyday arguments taken apart: a holiday, parking in the courtyard, school uniforms. Plus the catalogue of articles.

  • Figures

    Socrates, Plato, Aristotle and the roles people play in an argument: arguer, opponent, moderator, listener, judge.

  • History

    How people learned to argue: ancient conversations, the sophists, the school tradition of logic and modern argumentation theory.

Sources

  • Aristotle, "On Sophistical Refutations" (summary)
  • Plato's dialogues (summary, in general terms)
  • Textbooks of logic and argumentation theory

Names and dates in this reference have been checked against logic textbooks and summaries of ancient texts. Everything else is set out in general terms and with everyday examples, without judging particular people or events.