Ideas
Key ideas
To take arguments apart rather than simply take part in them, it helps to agree on the words. Below are the concepts found in any textbook of logic and argumentation theory. We explain them without formulas and with everyday examples, so they can be used right at the kitchen table or at a parents' meeting.
Most arguments get tangled not because the people involved are foolish, but because they have not agreed on what they are arguing about. A precise word for each part of an argument saves hours of pointless bickering.
How the material was selected: the glossary includes the concepts without which it is impossible to see how an argument is built and to tell an honest objection from a trick. We have simplified the strict textbook definitions while keeping their meaning.
What an argument is made of
- Thesis
- The claim a person defends in an argument. For example: "it's better to go to the seaside on holiday". Until the thesis is stated clearly, arguing about it is pointless: each person will be objecting to something of their own.
- Argument
- A reason in favour of the thesis, that is, a ground that should make it more convincing. For example: "at the seaside the children can swim every day". An argument can be checked, challenged or accepted as strong.
- Premise and conclusion
- Premises are the statements reasoning starts from; the conclusion is what follows from them. If the premises are true and the link between them and the conclusion is sound, the conclusion is worth accepting, even if it is unwelcome.
- Argument and example
- An example illustrates an idea but on its own rarely proves it. One successful pie does not prove that a recipe is good, just as one failed pie does not prove the opposite.
When reasoning breaks down
- Logical error
- A flaw in reasoning that means the conclusion does not follow from the premises. An error can be made by accident: a tired or agitated person easily skips a step in reasoning without noticing.
- Sophism
- Reasoning that looks correct but is built to mislead the other person. Unlike a simple error, a sophism is usually used deliberately, for the sake of an apparent victory.
- Trick
- Any move that helps win an argument without proving the thesis: changing the subject, needling the other person, scaring them with consequences, appealing to the opinion of the crowd. A table of the main tricks is in the sources section.
Rules of an honest argument
- Burden of proof
- The duty to support a claim with arguments lies with the person who makes it. The phrase "prove me wrong" shifts this duty onto the other person and by itself proves nothing.
- Disputes about facts and disputes about values
- In a dispute about facts you find out how things are: how long the journey will take, whether there is enough room in the courtyard. In a dispute about values you decide what matters more: quiet or convenience, saving money or comfort. The first can often be settled by checking, the second only by agreement.
- The principle of charitable reading
- Before objecting, state the other person's idea in the strongest and most reasonable form you can think of. If you refute the strong version, your answer will be worth something; if you refute a weak one, you are arguing with an imaginary opponent.
- The right to change your mind
- An honest argument assumes that each participant may change their mind on hearing a convincing argument. That is not a defeat but the result that made the conversation worthwhile.
See also
- Sources
How to read an ancient dialogue in summary, a table of tricks and the steps for taking apart someone else's argument.
- History
How people learned to argue: ancient conversations, the sophists, the school tradition of logic and modern argumentation theory.
- Analysis
Everyday arguments taken apart: a holiday, parking in the courtyard, school uniforms. Plus the catalogue of articles.
- FAQ
Short answers about this reference, about logical tricks and about how to argue without falling out.
Sources
- Textbooks of logic and argumentation theory
- Editorial materials of this reference
Names and dates in this reference have been checked against logic textbooks and summaries of ancient texts. Everything else is set out in general terms and with everyday examples, without judging particular people or events.