An independent secular reference about argumentation and logical tricks. It is not the website of a religious community, sells nothing and is not connected with the former site on this domain.

Figures

Figures

The art of argument has few authors in the usual sense: it has been practised by millions of nameless speakers. Even so, a few ancient names appear in every logic textbook. We tell you only what is reliably known about them, and then describe the roles people take in any argument, from a family one to a practice debate.

Names in the history of argument do not matter in themselves. They remind us that people thought about honest reasoning long before us, and that many of our mistakes were described and analysed long ago.

— Editors' thought

How the material was selected: this section includes only people about whom textbooks give verified information connected with the history of argument. We write only what is confirmed about them; the participants' roles are described without names.

Ancient names

Three figures without whom it is hard to picture the history of thinking about honest and dishonest argument.

Socrates

Socrates, executed in 399 BC, wrote nothing himself. His way of conducting a conversation through a sequence of questions is known above all from the dialogues of his pupil Plato. So when we speak of the Socratic method, we always speak of it as retold and in general terms: step by step, one speaker checks whether an opinion holds up against its own consequences.

Sources

Plato

Plato was a pupil of Socrates, and it is his dialogues that preserved for posterity the image of the teacher leading a conversation through questions. When reading these dialogues in summary, it helps to remember that they are literary works: the author shaped the conversation so that the reader could follow the train of thought.

Sources

Aristotle

Aristotle, who lived from 384 to 322 BC, wrote the treatise "On Sophistical Refutations". In it he examined the tricks debaters use to create the appearance of a refutation. The treatise belongs to his collection of logical works, later called the "Organon".

History

Roles in an argument

In any conversation where opinions clash, people take on certain roles. Sometimes one person switches between them as the conversation goes on. We describe these roles in general terms, without names.

Arguer

The one who puts forward a thesis and defends it. Their main duty is to say clearly what they are claiming and to back it up with arguments. A good arguer knows in advance what objections may come up.

Ideas

Opponent

The one who objects. Their task is not to crush the other person but to test how solid the thesis is. The most valuable thing an opponent can do is find the weak link and point it out calmly.

Sources

Moderator

The one who keeps an eye on the conversation: gives people the floor, brings them back to the topic, stops personal attacks. In a family argument this role is often taken by the calmest participant, even if nobody appointed them.

Analysis

Listener

The one who does not take part in the argument directly but forms their own opinion. It is for the listeners' sake that arguers sometimes resort to showy tricks, so an attentive listener is the best defence against dishonest moves.

FAQ

Judge in a practice debate

In practice debates there is sometimes a person who assesses not whose position they prefer but the quality of the arguments on both sides. It is useful to take this role mentally now and then in ordinary conversation too.

Ideas

How to read about people of the past

  • Separate reliable information from later anecdotes that travel from book to book and gather details along the way.
  • Do not trust striking sayings without a source: many words were attributed to ancient thinkers much later.
  • Remember that we know about Socrates from other people's texts, above all Plato's dialogues, not from his own writings.
  • Distinguish the author's idea from a character's idea: in a dialogue different speakers have their say, and not each of them speaks for the author.
  • If information about a person appears only in a popular retelling, check it against a textbook before repeating it.
  • History

    How people learned to argue: ancient conversations, the sophists, the school tradition of logic and modern argumentation theory.

  • Sources

    How to read an ancient dialogue in summary, a table of tricks and the steps for taking apart someone else's argument.

  • Timeline

    Key points in the history of argument: from the conversations of Socrates and Aristotle's treatise to the present day.

  • Ideas

    Thesis, argument, premise, conclusion, sophism, burden of proof and other concepts in plain words.

Sources

  • Aristotle, "On Sophistical Refutations" (summary)
  • Plato's dialogues (summary, in general terms)
  • Textbooks of logic and argumentation theory

Names and dates in this reference have been checked against logic textbooks and summaries of ancient texts. Everything else is set out in general terms and with everyday examples, without judging particular people or events.