Analysis
Analysis
Concepts and tables are useful, but the structure of an argument only really becomes visible in live examples. Below we take apart three invented but very familiar conversations: a family choosing a holiday, neighbours arguing about parking in the courtyard and a school meeting about uniforms. In each case we show the point at which the conversation turned from reasoning to a trick and how it could have been brought back to the point.
The most useful question after an argument that went badly is this: at what point did we stop discussing the subject and start discussing each other? Once you find that moment, it is easy to see what to do next time.
How the material was selected: we take everyday situations familiar to almost everyone and analyse them with the concepts from the glossary and the table of tricks. All participants are invented, and the arguments are simplified so that their skeleton is visible.
Case studies
A family chooses a holiday: why did the conversation about the route end in hurt feelings?
One spouse suggested going to the mountains, the other said: "Either the seaside or nowhere at all." That is a false dilemma: there were more options, including a trip to the mountains, to a lake or to another city. Then came: "Last time in the mountains it rained the whole time", which is generalising from one case. Finally, the children announced that all their classmates were going to the seaside, and that became an appeal to the majority. The argument could have been built differently: first agree on what each person expects from the holiday (quiet, swimming, new experiences) and only then compare places. It would then have been clear that the disagreement was not about facts but about values, and that it had to be settled by agreement rather than squabbling.
Neighbours argue about parking in the courtyard: where did the conversation lose its meaning?
Residents of one entrance asked their neighbours not to leave cars right by the door, because it was hard to get past with a pram. In reply they were asked whether they wanted cars to be unable to reach the building at all. That is a straw man: the request was retold in an absurd form. Then came: "You parked here yourselves last year", which is a personal attack that does not answer the question of whether the cars are in the way now. The conversation could have been brought back to the point if both sides had first described the problem in the same way: cars need space, and pedestrians need a way through. After that the argument turns from a confrontation into a search for a solution, for example marking out a separate spot for unloading.
A school meeting discusses uniforms: why did nobody convince anybody?
Some parents thought a single uniform was needed, others were against it. The first group said that a uniform instils discipline because children in uniform behave better, and they behave better because they wear a uniform. That is circular reasoning. The second group replied that the neighbouring school introduced a uniform and grades fell, that is, they reasoned on the principle of "after this, therefore because of this". On top of that, the discussion kept sliding from the question of whether a uniform is needed to the question of whether the chosen design looks nice, and that is changing the subject. It would have been more honest to split the argument into parts: what we want a uniform to achieve, whether there are grounds to think it does so, and only then what it should be like.
What do all three cases have in common?
In all three cases people were arguing less about facts than about what mattered more to them, but behaved as if it were about facts that one side knows and the other stubbornly refuses to accept. Tricks appeared exactly where arguments were lacking. And in all three cases the conversation could have been saved in the same way: stop, restate the question so that both sides agree with the wording, and only then carry on.
Catalogue of articles
This section will publish standalone articles written specifically for English-speaking readers: detailed analyses of tricks, explanations of concepts and new everyday examples of arguments.
- ROB RUN Boosting: Customer Checklist
A step-by-step customer checklist for ROB RUN boosting: what to check in the game first, what to ask a provider, and what to do before, during and after.
- Competitive Shooter Unlocks and Ranked Progression: Practical Approaches — Risks and Trade-Offs #1
An editorial look at Call of Duty progression: which unlocks record time, which passes involve money, and why only ranked standing is built to read skill.
- Overwatch 2: Rank Boost — Player Decision Guide
Field notes on Overwatch rank boosting: how to diagnose a stalled rank, what the rules say, which alternatives exist, and what to check before any decision.
- Exploring Escape from Tarkov boosting services and progression options: Gaming Culture
An explainer on the Escape from Tarkov debate over boosting and progression shortcuts: the arguments, the weak points on both sides, and the rules involved.
- GTA 6 Heists and Mission Planning: Player FAQ
A player FAQ on GTA 6 heists that sorts claims by evidence: what Rockstar has confirmed, what the series suggests, and what is still pure guesswork.
- Aion 2 transcendence: Mechanics, Preparation and Common Questions
What can and cannot be verified about Aion 2 transcendence content, how to prepare for group play, and how to judge outside help without risking an account.
Topics the editors are planning
- How to disagree in a meeting without sounding like you are attacking a colleague
- Why "it's just common sense" is not an argument
- Arguing over text messages: why tone gets lost and how to avoid misunderstandings
- How to say "I was wrong" gracefully and why it makes your next argument stronger
Editorial rules
- Articles in this catalogue are written separately for each language version and are not translations.
- Some articles link to third-party websites, including gaming services; we do not control their content, prices or terms.
- We do not publish advertising, rankings, prices or reviews.
See also
- Sources
How to read an ancient dialogue in summary, a table of tricks and the steps for taking apart someone else's argument.
- Ideas
Thesis, argument, premise, conclusion, sophism, burden of proof and other concepts in plain words.
- FAQ
Short answers about this reference, about logical tricks and about how to argue without falling out.
- History
How people learned to argue: ancient conversations, the sophists, the school tradition of logic and modern argumentation theory.
Sources
- Textbooks of logic and argumentation theory
- Editorial materials of this reference
Names and dates in this reference have been checked against logic textbooks and summaries of ancient texts. Everything else is set out in general terms and with everyday examples, without judging particular people or events.